Our Readers Disclose Their Favorite Whitening Toothpaste

We all want pearly white teeth, right? Some of us opt for pricey professional treatments but the majority of us turn to whitening toothpaste and strips. While some whitening toothpaste brands promise to give us a million-dollar smile, it's often hard to know which one will truly get the job done. We here at AOL Shopping conducted an unscientific poll with our readers and asked them to tell us which whitening toothpaste(s) is the best. Read on to see the results.

"The best whitening toothpaste I have found is Sensodyne Extra Whitening Toothpaste for Sensitive Teeth & Cavity Prevention. As someone who continually suffers from tooth sensitivity, it is difficult for me to find a whitening toothpaste that does not increase my sensitivity as many whitening treatments can. My dentist recommended that I use Sensodyne toothpaste to deal with my tooth sensitivity and I was happy to find that there was an extra-whitening version available. After using it for about two weeks, not only were my teeth less sensitive, they were also a few shades whiter than before, brushing twice a day. I now recommend this to all of my family and friends due to its effectiveness." -- Susan

"I do love my coffee and red wine, so I have tried a few whitening toothpastes through the years. With all the products out on the market claiming to be the best at giving you the same results as professional whitening at the dentist, only a couple have really stuck out as bringing me the most noticeable results after a couple of weeks' usage. Tom's of Maine is a natural blend of ingredients and a better choice for those looking for less chemicals in a toothpaste than those found in products from other leaders in the industry. The full name of this product is Tom's of Maine Natural Anti plaque Tartar Control Plus Whitening Toothpaste. It not only has a great peppermint flavor, but it controls plaque and tartar buildup, and you will notice a difference in your teeth in about two weeks. I bought this particular tube at Wild Oats, but you can find it online or at other natural food stores or pharmacies." -- Ikham

"After the jealousy of my boyfriend's glistening teeth took over me, I decided it was in my best interest to take control over the situation. I bought a tube of the kind he swears by, Crest 3D White Advanced Vivid Toothpaste. It's a mouthful to say, but it leaves you with a mouthful of pearly whites. With a saint on my toothbrush, and teeth two shades whiter, I can now attest to this as well. I began seeing results after only five days, and after a month, they are the whitest I've seem them in a while. The only downfall to this product is that it's not sold at my favorite local discount drug store, so I surrendered to CVS. Nonetheless, this product successfully exceeds all expectations of whitening toothpastes, and is a necessity in bathroom vanities everywhere." -- Jen

"I am an avid iced-tea and coffee drinker, which, unfortunately, can wreak havoc on my pearly whites. However, I use Aquafresh Extreme Clean Whitening Action twice a day, everyday to reverse the yellowing effects of my daily habits. This toothpaste is great because not only does it remove stains and keep my teeth white, but this toothpaste leaves my mouth feeling clean. It has some sort of magic foaming action that lets you actually feel your mouth getting cleaner and your teeth getting whiter. You can find Aquafresh Extreme Clean Whitening Action almost anywhere toothpaste is sold (they even sell a travel size so you never have to go without it!)." -- Randi

"I chose Crest Extra Whitening with Scope. The taste was a pleasant surprise. The paste easily dissolved in my mouth. It had a smooth texture and left no filmy residue. After two weeks of using, I did notice a a slight improvement in the coloration of my teeth. I definitely was not ready for the front page of GQ, but I was glad to see positive results." -- Ted

"It is a daily struggle fighting against the build-up that yellows and stains our teeth. For years I have searched for the perfect whitening toothpaste to solve this problem, and I have found it in Colgate Total Whitening Toothpaste. I have tried many other whitening products, and this has been the best and most effective by far. There are a few reasons I would recommend using this toothpaste brand if it is a whiter smile you desire. To begin, it only takes a few weeks to see an effect. It is unrealistic to expect instant results when using a whitening toothpaste, but Colgate has proven to be fairly quick. I like a toothpaste that gets the job done! Another reason this product is so great is that it lasts long-term. Sometimes, a toothpaste whitens your teeth only to fade soon after. I have not found this to be an issue, proving Colgate is a toothpaste you can trust. Finally, the minty fresh taste adds to the enjoyment. Some toothpastes have a funky taste, but Colgate gets the combination just right! If you are looking for a solution to your whitening problems I strongly urge you to go out and buy this product today. The lasting results will give you a lifetime of beautiful, clean teeth." -- Amy

"I'm a sucker for teeth whitening products, so I'm always sampling new options. One of my favorites to date is Rembrandt's Plus Premium Whitening Toothpaste. Not only is the packaging beautiful, but the results are also noticeable. I especially like the refreshing, non-overpowering minty flavor and the sudsy sensation that really makes you feel like its working. After brushing, I like to kick it up a notch by using Rembrandt's Whitening Mouthwash With Fluoride. This combo makes my mouth feel extra clean. With this combination, I noticed my teeth were whiter after using the product for a week." -- Wendy

Next: At-Home Teeth Whitening

Which whitening toothpaste do you use? Did it actually work?
Share your thoughts in the comments section below.
_________________________________________________________________________________________________